Originally Posted by
steve_d
I somewhat agree...but I guess it depends what people use the word belonging to mean...Tim Love came 5th at provincials last year if I recall, and everyone says he will do damage this year. Personally I am a little skeptic on anyone unable to place top 3 at provincials being able to 'do damage' at nationals the year later. 1 year is not a lot of time, and unless you either showed up out of shape and came top 5 in an easy class, then you will not 'do damage'...Belong their, yes, but be in contention...no, that takes YEARS from placing 5th in a province to going to nationals.
but yes, for sure 4th and 5th place finishers in the largest province in the hard weight classes should be allowed to compete at nationals...doesn't mean they will place, but neither does winning provincials! top 3 at nationals is no joke.
It also depends a lot on the weight class you were in...I DON'T believe a 5th place finisher in light middle or lower should compete at nationals...they will get slaughtered. Particularly when there is often less than 5 guys in those lighter classes! I think there were 6 in my class last year. Should all but 1 get to do nationals? seems a little easy.