Log in

View Full Version : A. SIlva vs Roy Jones Jr. - in Boxing???



Gib
12-03-2008, 07:29 PM
RIP Anderson, if it happens....

SOurce: http://www.mmaweekly.com/absolutenm/templates/dailynews.asp?articleid=5880&zoneid=2

Ultimate Fighting Championship middleweight titleholder Anderson Silva recently indicated that he would like to challenge Roy Jones, Jr. – once regarded as one of the top pound-for-pound boxers in the world – to a boxing match.

“Anderson really would love to fight Roy Jones, Jr. in a boxing match,” said Ed Soares, Silva’s manager. “It’s not just talk, we really would like to put that fight together.

“We respect Jones’ boxing ability and think he’s one of the best, but we’re tired of different boxers saying that MMA fighters aren’t technical. Anderson would love to fight Roy Jones in a boxing match under boxing rules to prove that MMA fighters are technical, too.”

It now appears that what started out as a dream bout may actually have some merit to it.

Even nationally syndicated sports talk host Jim Rome, on his Rome Is Burning television show on ESPN2, has picked up on the story. He isn’t a big proponent of the bout happening though, saying, “Silva should not box Roy Jones. Where’s the intrigue in that? The whole ‘would MMA beat boxing’ argument is a big waste of time; it’s irrelevant. Silva, the best MMAer in the world would get schooled, even by a way past his prime Roy Jones, if he ever did boxing. He can’t fight his way off the ropes with his knees, just as Jones wouldn’t last a minute with Silva in his cage.”

According to Soares, however, there are other people who think there might be some merit to putting Silva up against Jones in a boxing ring.

“I just spoke with Roy Jones’ management and they are very interested in it. They think it would break all kinds of pay-per-view records. It all kind of started as a dream of Anderson’s, but if the UFC would back it, it is something that we really would like to pursue.”

Jones’ management indicated that this could be a fight that would bring together the fractured factions of boxing and mixed martial arts. “They think it will actually bring together the boxing and MMA communities,” said Soares.

And that would have to be a big part of it, as he continued, “Anderson looks up to Roy Jones, and he would love to test his skills against him. At the same time, we are very loyal to the UFC and would love to represent the UFC in a boxing match with Jones.”

UFC president Dana White has been vocal in the past about a boxer stepping into MMA to challenge his fighters. Prior to his fight with Oscar De La Hoya, Floyd Mayweather, Jr. commented, “(the UFC) ain’t nothing but a fad… These are guys that couldn’t do boxing.” White fired back offering up then lightweight champion Sean Sherk in the Octagon as a proving ground for Mayweather, who then retracted much of what he said.

It is unclear, however, if White is willing to put up Silva in a boxing match, as he was unavailable for comment at the time of publication.

Jones is currently headed out of the country until next week, but his management told Soares that he was “flattered and excited” by Silva’s interest in a boxing match with him. The parties are expected to talk again once Jones returns.

MuSuLPhReAk
12-03-2008, 07:39 PM
Would be interesting to watch but my money would go on Jones.

St
12-03-2008, 08:13 PM
I would go with Silva.

guest
12-03-2008, 08:13 PM
what would happen to the world of boxing if jones lost?

champcar99
12-03-2008, 08:42 PM
I guess all the wins is getting to Silva's head, no ****IN way will he win or even come close to beating Jones....If Silva's looking for a reality check he has found it....IMO

champcar99
12-03-2008, 08:44 PM
Musul love the hair.....LMAO...

Gib
12-03-2008, 08:46 PM
Yeah, if Silva has a good showing, he would win respect, but no way he beats RJJ at his own game, even if RJJ is a few years out of the game. He has as much chance of beating RJJ in a boxing match as RJJ has of winning an MMA match against Silva.

turboturist
13-03-2008, 07:53 AM
what would happen to the world of boxing if jones lost?

Or if it was a real close fight?


The whole ‘would MMA beat boxing’ argument is a big waste of time; it’s irrelevant. Silva, the best MMAer in the world would get schooled, even by a way past his prime Roy Jones, if he ever did boxing. He can’t fight his way off the ropes with his knees, just as Jones wouldn’t last a minute with Silva in his cage.”


That says it all.

shithead
13-03-2008, 09:30 AM
Roy is a has been.

Mr.Freeze
13-03-2008, 10:53 AM
roy jones all the way!

bigdaddydrew123
13-03-2008, 01:29 PM
what would happen to the world of boxing if jones lost?
nothing he beat a washed up ex champ. if silva really wants to prove his technique is great , fight a current champ. not a glass jaw 5 years past his prime jones.

Musclehead
13-03-2008, 04:59 PM
I'd like to see it I guess. I'm sure Jones would smoke him, but it would be interesting.

shithead
13-03-2008, 08:10 PM
Silva wants in on the dough! I can see some MMAers making the move to boxing/wrestling in the future.

physique
13-03-2008, 09:53 PM
silva doesnt stand a hope in a straighht up boxing match, but if it were a all around fight, Roy Jones would eat his words that UFC is a fad and are guys that couldnt make it in the boxing world.

but i dont see silva beating jones in a straight up boxing match

guest
13-03-2008, 10:30 PM
nothing he beat a washed up ex champ. if silva really wants to prove his technique is great , fight a current champ. not a glass jaw 5 years past his prime jones.

i beg to differ. the fact that silva is stepping out of his realm matters a lot. look at all these responses about how jones will kill him straight boxing.

many people believe the mixed martial artist's hands are inferior to a boxer.....all things considered, jones should still be good enough to expose that no? especially on his own playing field.

PS. physique...who is silvia?

Gib
14-03-2008, 01:29 AM
RJJ is hardly washed up anyway. Hes what, early forties? Still woul dhave some seriously impressive hands on him. He lost a few fights (IMO) due to lack of interest. If he trains seriously, he will pick silva apart within 3 rounds.

bigdaddydrew123
14-03-2008, 01:42 PM
roy jones was great but hasnt been for a long time.look at how bad tarver has been since beating jones. no eway tarver would have touched jones in his prime. ya jones would beat silva but it would only prove they are 2 different sports. but if silva got lucky and conneected with a shot on jones it would prove nothing but the fact that 1 jones cant take a punch and 2 he would have never touched him 5 years ago. of cource 5 years ago silva wouldnt want any part of jones.

guest
14-03-2008, 02:19 PM
roy jones was great but hasnt been for a long time.look at how bad tarver has been since beating jones. no eway tarver would have touched jones in his prime. ya jones would beat silva but it would only prove they are 2 different sports. but if silva got lucky and conneected with a shot on jones it would prove nothing but the fact that 1 jones cant take a punch and 2 he would have never touched him 5 years ago. of cource 5 years ago silva wouldnt want any part of jones.

lol, so what if Silva out boxed him? i never said he would....i said what if he did?

champcar99
14-03-2008, 02:32 PM
Dana will never stop with his big mouth...lol...

bigdaddydrew123
15-03-2008, 11:08 AM
lol, so what if Silva out boxed him? i never said he would....i said what if he did?
then silva would be god.only chance he would have would be punchers chance, very slim punchers chance, any other outcome id be shocked

bigdaddydrew123
15-03-2008, 02:09 PM
thing is they were thouse big gloes to (boxes) so EVEN if Silva hit him, (by chance) week chin or not i think RJJ coud shake it off, as mma are not flat footed etc to put ALL weight in punch , now if was mma glove and that chace happened good niht..lol
ya and those few extra ounces are gonna slow you down over time. id still love to see in prime boxing champ verses in prime mma champ. anybody remember ali fighting asian wrestler. ali thought it was play time but wrestler took it for real. ali took beating on his legs cant remember outcome tho

Gib
15-03-2008, 07:21 PM
^^ It was an exhibition, so it ended, I believe, in a 'draw'. Boring as hell to watch though. Thats probably on youtube actually. I havent seen that since i was about 5 or 6, maybe ill look it up to make sure i remember it correctly lol.

BolicPower
15-03-2008, 09:20 PM
I used to teach MMA, and i'd think Roy would win as well, MMA fights are all rounded fighters, that originate from some disapline, ie boxing or bjj or something. BUT not even close the the level of Roy Jones. This is why a boxer 9 times outa 10 will not win, unless he gets a shot in.