Minimum post count before posting in hrt section?

[buildinthaskinnys]

I dont know if this is just me but I seem to have seen alot of people just make a few posts about their next cycle and then they bail, maybe it would add to the proffesionalism of the board if you had to post a little bit in other sections before posting here? maybe minimum of 100 posts?

[faller]

maybe minimum of 100 posts?

I'm thinking 700 posts :D

Just kidding, good idea though..

[gicantor]

I disagree. Why bother. How do you know they didn't read the info and just didn't feel like posting.

[buildinthaskinnys]

If they are 130 lbs and had trouble gaining 5 lbs in 4 years or whatever and so they decided to go with steroids, obviously they havent read the info thats here. I think It brings down the quality of th board thats all.

Heres couple good examples of quality. 3 posts all together last activity one day after this shit.

http://www.canadabodybuilding.com/forums/showthread.php?t=11745

Im just thinking a minimum post count would keep the fishers elsewhere, which would be a good thing woudnt it?

[kloan]

lmao...

At least it was posted in the Beginners section! ;)

[#8]

I think this is a good idea. 50-100 post count.

[kidmode]

More like a minimum IQ requirement.

[MuSuLPhReAk]

In consideration.

[JacktheThriller]

umm how bout a slap in the face because 99% of the questions asked are already answered in post threads lazy fckrs

[_Ragnar_]

im good with a min post count

[O-Train]

How about people have to make posts in the diet and or training sections before hand? None of that random thread off topic bullshit.

[ELCANADA]

I think its a great idea.....coming from a noob to the board who has yet to do his first pin. I have been training for the better part of my adult life (32 now) and still feel intimidated posting in the AAS section.

I feel for the vets who come on here and give there EXPERIENCE to noobs and come off as dicks. I feel for you guys who have to respond to shit like ...critic my first cycle....... 1000mg of tren and dbol..maybe test ......and what should i do for PCT?

In all honesty the best part of me jumping on AAS is reseaching the shit out of what I am going to be sticking into me (literally) I wish the rest whould do the same....again.....I feel for you guys who feel you have to respond to ****ing noob ass questions.

[LonelyBedouin]

How about people have to make posts in the diet and or training sections before hand? None of that random thread off topic bullshit.

^^ This.

I think instead of a post count minimum, it should be a rule that you need to post in the diet section to see if we can improve that first, as most people are not eating properly first and foremost

[ELCANADA]

More like a minimum IQ requirement.


^^^^ And this....if you finally figured out your diet...nailed your training and have enough basic science to know what the **** is going into you then.....maybe then your ok to post and ask a relevant AAS question..maybe then.

[Chunk]

it doesn't affect me either way, but consider that there are a lot of people who post a lot of off-topic stuff that doesn't pertain to bodybuilding (myself included). I am here to educate myself and read everything that I can, but I post a lot of fluff...I more than likely have less than 5% bodybuilding related posts...but that doesn't mean I'm here to freeload. "Get to know your sources", right?

[natenator]

How about a person having to post a vid of themselves benchimg before their allowed to post in the HRT section? ;)

[Ritch]

How about people have to make posts in the diet and or training sections before hand? None of that random thread off topic bullshit.

Exactly.

[monkey]

A lot of newbies enter forums like this to ask questions.. many of them won't have 100 post counts and a lot of them will require help fairly quickly...

Dunno, probably quite hard to discriminate. I will definitely bring down the growth on this board ( assuming this is MP's objective).
A lot of you guys were newbs too at some point.. and gained knowledge after posting a while

( I do admit that SOME idiots don't want to learn and think they know better anyways,, but that does not neccesarily have to do with post count).

[Ritch]

How about a person having to post a vid of themselves benchimg before their allowed to post in the HRT section? ;)

Oh brother...

[gsxr750]

They must first master the art of gaining muscle while losing body fat.

[MuSuLPhReAk]

HRT forum seems to be ok right now no? I don't read it religiously but when I browse it, I don't see anything out of hand. Am I missing something?

[kloan]

yeah i dunno what the problem is either...

[monkey]

They must first master the art of gaining muscle while losing body fat.

Lol

[Atarii]

Just thought I'd say hello, been reading everyone's posts for the past 2 1/2 years. I just don't "chit chat" that much, I'm sure there's lots of people just like me out there.... or the flip side is that they don't want to be wrong and have people berate them :S I've seen this allot on forums EVERYWHERE.

later

[natenator]

They must first master the art of gaining muscle while losing body fat.
bahahahaha

[ironwill]

They must first master the art of gaining muscle while losing body fat.

awesome......a new guru......lol

[tiramisu]

Lord love a duck. Maybe the stanford-binet and the myers-briggs should be applied for minimum intelligence and personality standards.

[kloan]

Lord love a duck. Maybe the stanford-binet and the myers-briggs should be applied for minimum intelligence and personality standards.

Uh, yeah... you lost me. Does that mean I fail?

[rob66679]

HRT forum seems to be ok right now no? I don't read it religiously but when I browse it, I don't see anything out of hand. Am I missing something?

Everything is the best it's ever been since I've been here.
Theres no more guys making a first post asking about a certain UG lab
( obvious repping/schilling )...... The politics are out of it completely.
There are still people with no clue asking questions that prove their not ready for AAS, but that happens everywhere. After they take a good flaming they probably rethink their cycle plan....

Night and day difference compared to before the change IMHO.
I don't really see how changing things would improve anything.

[Reaver.]

Seems fine the way it is :S

[_Ragnar_]

On second thought all a minimum post requirement would do is flood the vets inboxes with PMs. That would be more annoying than stupid posts.

[PdH]

Personally, I'm not really sure what the problem is. The HRT section certainly isn't overrun with redundant posts these days. Why the need for regulation?

[cog]

One time I had this guy working for me,about 25 or so,he had just come off cycle about 2 weeks ago weighing about 250 at 5'10 or so.In those two weeks he dropped about 15 lbs.His buddy had done the honors for him,he didn't even know what it was.In the next six weeks I ran 45 lbs off him!He had no plan of any kind for PCT.He knew he was getting smaller,but when he finally stepped on the scale he was really choked!A little knowledge would have gone a long way.:)

[hommes]

i would think an even 1000 post count, cause by the time you get there you won't ramble on and on. you'll get straight to the point.