DJ vs Fouad vs Ed Nunn - 2009 Europa Super Show

[canadianmuscle0803]

1

[canadianmuscle0803]

2

[C-money]

i think fouad/nunn for first and second(could go either way) DJ 3rd

I do really like Nunns physique, lots of potential....

[natenator]

James because of his improvements. Nunn does look awesome. Great physique.

Fouad Looks dynamite as well, It's really hard to judge the 3. I'd like to see the score cards, they're probably really close... just a few points difference.
was 20 points between Fouad and DJ in tampa...

[natenator]

wow, I would have thought like 5 or 6.
me too. again why I think the judging is bullshit at both shows.

Giving Ben P 3rd was a joke too.

[canadianmuscle0803]

whoever voted for DJ- you need to get on birth control asap

whoever voted for ED Nunn- although i can see where your coming from, but he needs a shit load more mass in his upper body to even be compared to Fouad, structure wise he has ALL the tools, i think his frame is amazing.. but he needs an easy 15 lbs on his frame to be compared to the top level guys in the IFBB..

[canadianmuscle0803]

the birth control joke ha, was an attempt to poke humor at DJ's gut, having said that.. DJ was a hell of a lot better this week then the previous week..

[phatkid77]

holy shit... ed nunn...

i disagree with you in that he needs 15lbs..... his waist is super tiny as well, and i feel his arms and shoulders are on par with HOSS... maybe some chest and of course back width....but he definitely holds his own....

phats

[steve_d]

holy shit... ed nunn...

i disagree with you in that he needs 15lbs..... his waist is super tiny as well, and i feel his arms and shoulders are on par with HOSS... maybe some chest and of course back width....but he definitely holds his own....

phats

I think he meant 15 pounds to compete with the TOP in IFBB. Once could argue fouad needs at least that as well to compete with the top in the IFBB.

I like Nunn the best of the 3, and would have had him 1st, Fouad 2nd. You can say he isn't balanced and needs a bigger chest or whatever, but it is just one bodypart, he's more ripped, and dominates quite a bit in the other poses. Winners aren't determined on balance and symmetry - it helps, but symmetry is only one part of the equation. say someone has perfect symmetry and is 50 pounds smaller then a guy with decent symmetry, I am sure everyone would agree the bigger guy would win.

As a judge, you gotta figure out where you draw the line in symmetry, conditioning, size, etc.

On a side note, I still don't like where they don't seem to draw the line anywhere for Dennis James - I am not a fan.

[canadianmuscle0803]

^ i usually dont rep anyone cause i forget to but after reading your post you got a rep.. nice post man..